Premium credit cards may offer higher earn rates, travel insurance, lounge access, purchase protection, or extended warranty coverage in exchange for an annual fee. Fees, earn rates, insurance terms, and welcome offers change. Review the current card agreement and benefit certificates before comparing products.
To estimate value, add only the rewards and benefits you expect to use, then subtract the card fee and any extra spending the card encourages. Compare the result with a no-fee card using the same spending categories and current issuer terms.
Do not assign an insurance benefit a value without checking the covered people, trip limits, age limits, exclusions, deductibles, and eligibility rules. Compare card coverage with standalone policies only when the terms are genuinely equivalent.
Carrying a balance can cost more than any rewards earned. Check the card's current purchase interest rate and pay the statement balance in full whenever possible.
No-fee cards can be better for lighter spenders, but their rewards, category limits, and eligibility rules also vary. Compare current issuer terms instead of relying on a headline earn rate.
Some people use one card for its strongest eligible category and a no-fee card elsewhere. This only helps when the added rewards exceed any fee and the extra complexity does not encourage overspending. Review your cards against current terms and actual spending at renewal.
Worth It If You...
- People whose eligible rewards and benefits they actually use exceed the annual fee
- Travellers who have checked that the card insurance fits their trips and other coverage
- People who can pay each statement in full and understand the card's category limits
- Anyone who values airport lounge access, purchase protection, or extended warranty
Skip It If You...
- People whose expected rewards and used benefits do not cover the fee
- Anyone whose interest charges exceed the additional rewards and benefits
- People who don’t travel and won’t use travel insurance perks
- Those who won’t bother optimizing which card to use for which purchase
Pros
- +May offer higher earn rates on selected categories
- +May include travel insurance, subject to the certificate and eligibility rules
- +Airport lounge access on premium cards
- +Purchase protection and extended warranty coverage
- +Concierge services and exclusive offers on top-tier cards
Cons
- −Annual fee is a guaranteed cost before you earn anything
- −Only worthwhile if you pay the balance in full every month
- −Perks are wasted if you don’t travel or use the insurance
- −Multiple premium cards mean multiple fees
- −Temptation to overspend to "justify" the fee
The Bottom Line
Compare the current fee with rewards and benefits you will actually use, and include the value of a no-fee alternative. A card fee does not make sense if interest or extra spending outweighs the benefits.
What to Read Next
Get Canadian money tips in your inbox
New guides, tools, and savings strategies. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.